The first in a series (A Double Death on the Black Isle, 2011; Beneath the Abbey Wall, 2012), A. D. Scott’s debut novel places 21st century issues in a mid-twentieth century context. Post-World War II British – or in this case Scottish – mysteries tend to be of the cozy variety, depicting a gentle and genteel lifestyle in which a citizen-sleuth often solves the crime before a more or less inept police officer. “Small Death” retains the inept police officer but the bumbling is far from innocent. And the citizen-sleuth is a journalist, newly come to the Highlands from Glasgow aiming both to turn the small weekly into a modern, dynamic newspaper and to leave old wounds behind. That, of course, is not to be and a little boy’s death by drowning forces many secrets into the open. In that time and place PTSD was called “shellshock” and referred only to the most obviously damaged veterans; domestic violence was hidden from even the best of friends; unwed mothers were forced to give up their babies for adoption; pedophilia was covered over by victims and authorities. At the same time everyone knew these secrets that, perhaps as women began to more strongly resist their traditional roles, began to emerge from the shadows. John McAllister shows more patience in gathering evidence than with his tradition-bound staff, despite moments in which he is overcome by the emotions his growing knowledge rouses, and proves himself to be a determined man of action. The perpetrators will not surprise you (much) but the conclusion is wholly unexpected. The complex “everyone is related to everyone else” connections can be a bit hard to keep straight and it’s often unclear whether McAllister whether his predecessor Don McLeod is currently his subordinate or his superior. A few passages read more “romance” than mystery. But the bits of Highland Scots dialect add delicious flavor and readers will certainly want more John McAllister.
Welcome to Newburgh Free Library’s blog Inspirations: a blog for readers and viewers.
At the Newburgh Free Library we would like to connect our community to the books and movies we love as well as get feedback from you on the books and movies that you love and want to share with others.
Of course we plan on introducing new titles that are coming out on the shelves at NFL, but we also hope to connect you with a hidden gem or two – things that you might not have discovered on your own. At our new blog, look forward to reading about staff picks, patron picks, nonfiction, mystery, and the newest in street fiction. It’s all up for discussion in Inspirations.
- adaptations Adirondacks adult books for young adults Alternative Histories atmospheric audiobooks awards based on books biography black history month book clubs book groups book review books cancer censorship character-driven classics coming of age compelling complex debut novel disturbing doris kearns goodwin dvds essays family relationships fantasy fast-paced fiction Florida good vs. evil haunting historical fiction history Hudson Valley Poets Hugo awards humorous immigrant experience Jane Austen Japan Kate Atkinson literary fiction literature love magic realism memoirs morgan freeman moving mysteries mystery national book award National Poetry Month Newburgh Free Library nonfiction nonfiction; books P.D. James PEN/Faulkner Award poetry psychological psychological fiction psychological thriller pulitzer prize reading romance satire science fiction science writing short stories suspenseful thought provoking thriller walter mosley witty WWII
Our Favorite Quotes“There are worse crimes than burning books. One of them is not reading them.” - Joseph Brodsky